Twenty years of building bridges
Robert-Jan Smits, President of Neth-ER, opened the conference after a musical performance by students at the Royal Conservatoire The Hague, a member of the European Universities alliance IN.TUNE. He looked back on twenty years in which Neth-ER has served as the bridge between the Dutch education, research and innovation sectors and Brussels. Competitiveness, resilience, the wellbeing of our societies and our democracy, he argued, all depend on one thing: knowledge. His message to the room was clear: “Double the budget!”
“€200 billion is not a wish list”
Christian Ehler, Member of the European Parliament and rapporteur for the next Framework Programme, delivered the keynote, just days after the Industry, Research and Energy Committee (ITRE) adopted the Parliament’s position with 67 votes in favour and one against. “Parliament speaks with one voice on Horizon Europe,” he said and this, of course, includes its calls for €200 billion, an independent Horizon Europe closely connected to the European Competitiveness Fund (ECF), a strong role for experts, and a strictly civil programme. “€200 billion is not a wish list, it is what Europe needs,” Ehler stressed. The European budget cannot offer more for everything, but it does need more for research and innovation.
“Bring Brussels to the Hague”
Ehler also called for broader work programmes with fewer topics and more money per topic, to create critical mass, and for funding decisions within ten weeks. Research and innovation should lead the way to investment, rather than industry setting the priorities for innovation. He closed with a request to the audience: for twenty years, Neth-ER has brought the voice of the Dutch knowledge sector to Brussels; now it is time to bring Brussels to The Hague and ask the Dutch government to support the Parliament’s position. In the Q&A that followed, Babs van den Bergh, Vice-President of Neth-ER and Director of Universities of the Netherlands, asked how the knowledge sector can convince policymakers. Ehler’s advice: tell them a story about how investment in research and innovation improves competitiveness. “If we want to have a say on what the world should look like, we need to have chips on the table.”
Pooling forces behind shared priorities
In a conversation moderated by Jurgen Rienks, Director of Neth-ER, the two co-chairs of the European Research Area and Innovation Committee (ERAC), Marc Lemaître, Director-General for Research and Innovation at the European Commission, and Feite Hofman, Director-General at the Dutch Ministry of Education, Culture and Science, discussed why Europe needs a strong research and innovation programme. According to Lemaître, 27 national research policies no longer provide the critical mass needed in today’s global technological race: “27 quantum strategies don’t make us competitive.” The Framework Programme should therefore pool European and national resources behind shared priorities, while excellence remains the guiding principle. Hofman agreed that the budget needs to increase, and that ERAC aims for less fragmentation and more alignment between national and European strategies.
A collective mindset, or failure on a grand scale
Both stressed that the key is a shared sense of purpose. “If we continue as we did in the past, we will fail, and fail at a grand scale,” Lemaître warned, while expressing hope that the willingness to work together is growing. He also noted that the outside world looks at Horizon Europe with admiration: “The Framework Programme is a magnet for the rest of the world.” Hofman, meanwhile, called for less focus on individual instruments and more on the bigger message: European research and innovation helps to safeguard the European way of life.
Don’t miss out on Erasmus+
Marjan Hammersma, President of Avans University of Applied Sciences and board member of Neth-ER, and Jeannette Oostijen, board member of the MBO Raad, discussed the place of education in the next MFF. Oostijen pointed to the opportunities for vocational students: only a small part of the Erasmus+ budget reaches them, while Europe urgently needs skilled workers. Shorter exchanges, Centres of Vocational Excellence (CoVEs) and the recognition of diplomas and microcredentials can help. Hammersma called for holding course on Erasmus+ and continuing to invest in all its parts, including the European Universities alliances: “We should work together to demonstrate that we cannot miss Erasmus+, and that it actually needs a bit more budget.”
Student perspectives: Europe in practice
Three student pitches showed what European cooperation means in practice. Mónica and Martien described how IN.TUNE brings them into contact with different musical traditions across Europe, from Dutch to German and Italian perspectives on music: “Different cultural backgrounds aren’t an obstacle but elevate our skills as musicians.” Tim de Kam, team leader of offshore wind technicians at Ørsted and a former student of Scalda, showed how close cooperation between vocational education and industry within the CoVE in Zeeland paved the way from the classroom to offshore wind. And Jelle Bos of Erasmus University Rotterdam shared how his Erasmus exchange in Copenhagen broadened his perspective: “The outside perspective on my own culture is something no other education programme could have given me.”
‘Double the budget!’, a case that must be made until the final decision
In his closing remarks, Jurgen Rienks brought the messages of the evening together: the Framework Programme needs real ambition, Europe needs a collective mindset, and education, from vocational training to universities, belongs at the heart of Europe’s future. The students showed what that ambition delivers in practice. His call to the audience was clear: “Double the budget. We count on all of you, our members, partners and friends, to make that case until the final decision.
Context
Each year, Neth-ER organises a network conference in Brussels, bringing together policymakers, members of the knowledge community, students and journalists. Last year’s edition featured contributions from Robbert Dijkgraaf, Vanessa Debiais-Sainton and René Repasi, among others. Read last year’s article and watch the aftermovie here.